There
are many long-term care insurance carriers in the market today.
The earliest long-term care contracts were designed to provide
nursing home coverage only. Further, earlier contracts were
very restrictive in their language, not covering Alzheimer’s
disease and requiring nursing home placement to occur following
a hospital stay. In more recent years, contracts have become
much more versatile and will often cover not only facility
care, but home care and community care as well.
In
our opinion, one of strongest considerations when evaluating
a long-term care provider is the length of time they have
been marketing the product. There are only a handful of players
in the market today that have the experience with pricing
the contract appropriately and paying claims. One of the worst
possible scenarios would be to purchase an inexpensive long-term
care contract today only to find out that you can’t
afford the large future increases that will likely occur due
to an inexperienced carrier’s under pricing the product
at the onset. A worst scenario might be that they quickly
get out of the business due to high losses at claims time.
Even
the strongest carriers do not guarantee that they will not
have to raise the premium at some future date. However, they
have a good understanding of how to price the product up front,
and future increases will only be tolerated if the carrier
can prove that the claims incurred dictate an increase.
As
independent agents, Jolles Insurance can represent the majority
of carriers available to you in the market place. It is also
important to note that the cost to allow us to represent your
long-term care needs will be exactly the same as any other
agent can provide or, for that matter, the same cost than
if you went through the carrier directly. With that in mind,
our clients appreciate the added value service in helping
select an appropriate carrier and benefit design. We will
help you in the underwriting process to secure the best possible
offer. We pride ourselves in providing top-level service after
the sale and especially at the time you need it the most --
when you need to go on claim.
* Jolles
Insurance reviews the leading competitive long-term care contracts
available on the market. Although we regularly review the
specimen contracts from each of the carriers we represent,
we do not guarantee the accuracy of information provided.
This information is for general plan comparison purposes only
and is presented to facilitate a better understanding of significant
plan differences between the leading LTC carriers. Any references
are based on the best available information and the actual
contract should be consulted as the final authority. All information
should be verified before making a decision on a specific
policy or plan design. If you are considering replacing a
current insurance plan, do not terminate your existing policy
until you have received your new policy and verified the provisions
and premium
LTC
Analysis
Jolles
Insurance
represents most of the
major players in the
long-term care insurance marketplace. We pride
ourselves on our ability
to help our clients secure
the most appropriate
carrier and product
design for their needs.
The
first distinction in evaluating the contracts deals with
the method that the carriers pay the daily benefit. There
are two basic types of contracts: reimbursement contracts
and indemnity contracts. A reimbursement contract means
that you send the bills to the company and the company
pays you back for the allowable expenses up to the policy
limits. Each day that a reimbursement is less than the
maximum daily benefit amount, the money is kept in a pooled
account. This money would then be available to extend
the benefit period until all monies in the pooled account
are exhausted.
Usually under an indemnity contract once you’ve triggered
benefits and met the waiting period, the insurer cuts you
a check for the daily maximum benefit for each day you have
at least one eligible service. This provides you with the
flexibility to utilize the payment in any way you see fit,
i.e., chores, cleaning, lawn care, shopping, etc. Generally
speaking, indemnity plans are more expensive than reimbursement
plans.
The
next point of comparison is determining satisfaction of the
elimination period. Some carriers begin counting days of service
following approval of carrier to doctor’s certification
that an individual requires assistance for two or more ADL’s
or suffers cognitive impairment. Other carriers require that
the individual or some form of insurance is paying for assistance
in order for a day to qualify towards the elimination period.
There are also various differences in how days are qualified.
For example, if one day requires assistance within a week,
some companies count it as a week satisfied. There are some
contracts on the market that will waive the elimination period
for home care if the carrier’s approved case manager
agrees the care is needed and appropriate.
Almost all carriers state that once the elimination period
is satisfied, it is satisfied for life. An even better definition
shared by some companies goes one step further in stating
that each elimination day satisfied is satisfied for life.
An additional point that needs to be understood when comparing
plans that require satisfaction of the elimination period
is that most carriers require that the elimination period
be satisfied within a defined period of time, such as one
year or 18 months. If it is not satisfied in that period,
a new elimination period would need to be satisfied. Avoid
contracts that require a new waiting period when you move
from home care to nursing-home care.
Long-Term
Care Plan Design
The
younger you purchase a long-term care policy the more realistic
it will be for you to design a policy that will give you the
peace of mind your coverage will do an effective job for you
in the future, when you need it. Properly designing your long-term
care contract can be the difference between throwing away
years of premiums or having your policy be the effective insurance
that you intended it to be: protecting your assets, your choices,
and your dignity in the distant future.
You
have to use vision when you design your policy. Think about
how far we have come over the past 20 years in our advances
in health care, medicine, and longevity. The pace of advancement
does not slow down. What will seniors face 20 or 30 years
from now in terms of long-term care needs? Those of us who
market long-term care often say, “the longer you live,
the more likely that you will need long-term care insurance.”
Would it be smart to look at today’s statistics which
state that the average length of time an individual requires
long-term care is between 2-1/2 and 3 years? Long-term care
is insurance we buy today for a need that will likely not
present itself until we are 80, 90, or even older. Many of
the provisions that you consider when designing your policy
need to take this into account. For example:
Benefit
Period: Remember that the industry average
of 2-1/2 years is just that, an average. 50% of the individuals
spend less time requiring long-term care assistance and
50% of the individuals spend more time. If you consider
what is pointed out above, it is very easy to visualize
a future where the oldest members of our population are
receiving higher levels of personal care, medical care,
and nutritional care. It would be interesting to know the
effect that today’s assisted living facilities have
had in increasing the longevity of individuals who require
assistance.
Inflation
Protection: Long-term care inflation has been
rising at a much higher rate than general inflation. Most
sources use 5% as a benchmark for long-term care inflation.
For younger policyholders 65 and under it is highly recommended
that a 5% compound inflation rider be included in the contract.
If inflation continues at 5% a year, a 60 year old with
an initial daily benefit of $150 and reaching age 80 in
20 years would need a benefit of $397.99/day. How good will
your policy be if it only provides $150/day?
Elimination
Period: When you select your elimination period,
you have to understand the impact that inflation will have
on your policy as well. Let’s assume that you feel
you can handle a 90-day elimination period (that means that
you will pay the daily benefit for the first 90 days that
you need services). Based on a $150 daily benefit, you would
expect to pay $13,500 before your benefits kick in. Imagine
that long-term care inflation continues at 5% over the next
20 years. You might find out you will need to pay $35,819.10.
This is based on the average daily cost of care increasing
to $397.99/day.
There
are a number of other features to weigh before selecting the
most appropriate benefit design to meet your specific needs.
LONG-TERM
CARE CONTRACT DEFINITIONS
Maximum Daily Benefit (MDB)
Let’s begin with the Maximum Daily Benefit or MDB. The
MDB is the maximum amount your policy will pay for expenses
incurred on any one given day. If you choose a fully integrated
policy, it will be the maximum benefit paid on any given day
for services received in a Nursing Home, Assisted Living Facility,
Hospice Facility, or Respite Care.
Home Care Benefits are paid on a Monthly Maximum Benefit (MMB).
In other words it is the maximum amount paid for home care
services or community service received in any one calendar
month. This monthly benefit is determined by multiplying your
maximum daily benefit times the number of days in the month.
The current average cost for nursing home stay in Maryland
is about $150 per day. However, if you telephone several homes
in your area, you can get an exact cost for your geographical
location. At $150 per day you’re looking at over $50,000
per year for care. (Note: based on 2003 costs.)
Policy Maximum
Next
we need to consider Policy Maximum. This is the maximum amount
that your contract will pay over the entire term of your policy.
The policy maximum can be thought of as a pool or bucket of
money available for benefits. Your bucket is determined by
multiplying your MDB x the period you select. Options might
include a 2,3,4,5,6,10 or Unlimited period. For example, if
you used a 5-year factor with a $100 MDB, your bucket of money
would start with $182,500.00 worth of benefits.
5 Years x 365 days per year = 1825 days x $100 = $182,500
If you select a benefit increase rider, that amount will grow
each year. The policy will pay benefits as long as there is
money in your bucket. If you select an unlimited or lifetime
option, then the policy will pay the MDB as long as you qualify
for care.
Elimination Periods
Now we can look at the elimination period. The elimination
period works like the deductible on any other liability insurance.
Instead of using dollars, long-term care insurance uses days.
It is the number of days you are responsible for paying before
your policy begins to pay benefits. Options might include
0,15,30,60,90 or 100 days. So, if you had a 60-day elimination
period and the cost of care was $100 per day, you would have
to pay $6,000 out of pocket before the policy would begin
to pay.
You need to select an elimination period that you are financially
comfortable with, keeping in mind that the cost of care will
most likely continue to rise with inflation.
Benefit Increase Riders
One of the most important considerations should be adding
a benefit increase option to your policy. This rider will
allow your MDB to increase each year, helping you keep up
with future increased costs in care. There are 3 options available:
simple, compound or Guaranteed Purchase Option Rider (GPOR)
which is based on the Consumer Price Index.
The GPOR provides an automatic increase of the Daily Benefit
every three years, based on the Consumer Price Index. The
amount of the increase is generally not less than 15.76% (5%
compounded over 3 years). In most cases, the purchase option
will be offered to you every 3 years. If you decline a total
of 4 increases, the rider will terminate, and no additional
offers will be made. All increases will be purchased at your
attained age or your age at the time the offer is extended.
The Simple Benefit Increase Rider provides an automatic increase
in your Daily Benefit on each policy anniversary. The increase
will be 5% of the original Daily Benefit. For example if you
had a $100 Daily Benefit on your 1st policy anniversary, the
benefit would increase to $105 per day. On the 2nd anniversary
it would increase to $110 per day etc. With the Simple Benefit
Increase Rider, your Daily Benefit would double in 20 years.
The Compound Benefit Increase Rider provides for an automatic
increase of the Daily Benefit on each policy anniversary of
an amount equal to 5% of the previous year’s Daily Benefit.
For example, if you had a $100 Daily Benefit on your 1st policy
anniversary, your benefit would increase to $105 per day.
On the 2nd anniversary it would increase 5% of $105 to $110.25
per day. The benefit would continue compounding over the life
of the policy. With the Compound Benefit Increase Rider your
Daily Benefit would double in 15 years.
Activities of Daily Living
Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) are activities you perform
everyday. The ADLs most companies use are:
Bathing:
Your ability to wash yourself by sponge bath or in either
a tub or shower, including the task of getting in and out
of the tub or shower.
Continence: Your ability to maintain control of your
bowel and bladder function, or when unable to maintain control
of bowel or bladder, the ability to perform associated personal
hygiene (including caring for catheter or colostomy bag.
Dressing: Your ability to put on and take off all
items of clothing and any necessary braces, fasteners or artificial
limbs.
Eating: Your ability to feed yourself by getting
food into your body from a receptacle (such as a plate or
cup or table) or by a feeding tube or intravenously.
Toileting: Your ability to get to and from the toilet,
to get on and off the toilet and to perform associated hygiene.
Transferring: Your ability to change positions such
as moving from bed to standing, chair to standing, bed to
chair and the reverse of these activities.
Additional Benefit Definitions
Substantial Human Assistance means either actual
hands-on physical assistance or standby or supervisory assistance
by another individual, without which you would not be able
to perform an Activity of Daily Living.
Severe Cognitive Impairment means a deficiency
in: your short term or long-term memory; orientation as to
person, place or time; deductive or abstract reasoning or
judgment as it relates to safety awareness.
Chronically
Ill Individual means an insured who has been certified
that they are expected to be unable to perform, without substantial
human assistance, at least 2 ADLs for a period of at least
90 days from inception of the illness or injury, or have a
severe cognitive impairment that requires substantial supervision
to protect the insured or others from threats to health and
safety.
Care-Coordinator means a Registered Professional
Nurse or Licensed Social Worker who is trained and experienced
in providing care coordination services.
Plan of Care means a written individualized plan
of services developed by a Licensed Health Care Professional.
Respite Care means the supervision and care of persons
with deficiencies in ADLs or who are severely cognitively
impaired. It is provided when a family member or other caregiver
who normally provides long-term care services on a regular
basis takes a short-term leave or rest from their caregiving
responsibilities.
Hospice Care means services that are designed to
provide palliative care and to alleviate physical, emotional,
social and spiritual discomforts of a terminally ill individual,
as well as providing supportive care to the primary caregiver
and family of the terminally ill individual.
Caregiver Training means training you or a person
designated to assist you in the proper use and care of a therapeutic
device or caregiving procedure.
Emergency Response System means a communication system
installed in your home, which is used to call for assistance
in the event of a medical emergency.
Alternate Plan of Care means health care or personal
care services that are not specifically covered by this policy
but which you, your Physician and your care coordinator, and
the insurance company agree would be appropriate to meet your
long-term care needs.
Bed Reservation allows the insured to be reimbursed
for the reservation of a room and bed in a nursing or assisted
living facility if he or she has to leave the facility for
any reason.
Waiver of Premium eliminates premiums on a month-to-month
basis while receiving certain types of care.
Disclaimer: These definitions are for informational purposes
only. Policy benefits and definitions may vary by state. Please
refer to your contract for specific definitions and terms.
UNDERWRITING
Jolles
Insurance will take into consideration your health history
and other underwriting considerations before making a final
recommendation. By understanding your specific health history,
we will take the following steps:
We will check with the leading carriers for their specific
underwriting rules.
As part of our initial process, we work closely with nurses
who understand the underwriting issues for most of the
major carriers. They assist us in focusing on the carriers
that will likely provide the most favorable underwriting.
We will, whenever possible, talk directly with an underwriter
to determine if there are specific requirements that we
can obtain to facilitate a better underwriting outcome.
We will follow-up with all parties throughout the underwriting
process to assure that you get the best possible offer.
There are many insurance companies who have recently entered
into the long-term care marketplace. Some have set up relationships
with other existing companies, while others have designed
new products that are untested. Because of the ever changing
long-term care industry, it is very difficult for inexperienced
carriers to offer products without the historical advantage
of underwriting new business and projecting the cost of future
claims. It is for this reason that we strongly suggest that
one of the most important considerations is selecting an experienced
carrier with a long track record in the long-term care marketplace.
Even in underwriting there are substantial differences between
the top carriers. Depending on the medical history, one carrier
might offer a preferred underwriting status while another
might issue a rated policy or even decline the applicant.
With a very high degree of accuracy, we can determine the
likely underwriting result before an application is even submitted.
It is important to deal with an agent who specializes in long-term
care. Brian Jolles has spent years learning the marketplace
and understanding how to properly evaluate the competing products.
Further, as a Certified Senior Advisor (CSA), he works with
many other professionals who specialize in the senior market.
His overall understanding of insurance, estate, and financial
planning and how the various pieces fit together to determine
specific needs are essential to providing the best possible
assistance.
Once it is determined that long-term care insurance is an
appropriate option for a client’s needs, our next step
is to have the client complete a health screening questionnaire.
This tool allows us to communicate with nurses and underwriters
to begin narrowing down the realistic and most appropriate
options. It is our strong recommendation that you never submit
an application without having a reasonable expectation based
on the work of the agent that you are likely to receive a
favorable underwriting result.